The Trap of Trauma
10/11/2026
JRS 92
Selected Scriptures
Transcript
JRS 92
10/11/2026
The Trap of Trauma
Selected Scriptures
Jesse Randolph
This morning I'm going to take some time to address an issue which is gaining a stronger and stronger foothold in the modern-day church. It's an issue which I believe if it's not addressed it has the potential to lead many well-meaning Christians, perhaps some of you, astray. It's an issue which has potential to weaken many otherwise faithful and solid churches along the way as the sufficiency of God's Word is called into question and the primacy of the local church is called into doubt. The issue that we are going to take some time to address today is this. There is a rising tide of otherwise well-meaning Believers in Jesus Christ who are being swept away by a powerful current of thought which originated in the seas of secularism, but which has since made its way onto the shores of Christendom. According to this current of thought, hurting people, suffering people, traumatized people need to be recognized, and they need to be embraced as hurting people, as suffering people, as traumatized people. As though they are a separate category of Christians for whom God's Word is entirely adequate and for whom God's Church is entirely fitting. For these individuals, though, their hurts and their sufferings and their traumas would have, just a few decades ago, been rightly categorized as spiritual problems. Their afflictions are now being coded as medical problems or mental health problems or clinical problems or problems which require a therapeutic solution or problems which require the help of a so-called professional. Just a few decades ago those sufferings and struggles that individuals like that would have experienced would have been rightly handled with proper pastoral shepherding care and through the loving encouragement and exhortation from fellow members of the same body of Believers, i.e. the Church. They would have been communicated with and ministered to in a local church context with an open Bible and with compassionate hearts and with the Spirit of God at work. But now more and more the hurts and the sufferings and the pains of people, even Christian people, are being given more clinical labels and softer sounding secular diagnoses. Ones which center not on God and His Word, ones which focus not on Christ, the One who suffered in the ultimate sense, but ones which focus rather on self and the sufferer's self-evaluation of their own experiences and their own perspectives and their own trauma.
To give you a better sense of what I'm referring to I'm going to read to you two real life profiles from two real people, two adults, one male and one female. The first is from a man named Jonathan. He says, “My name is Jonathan. I've been a Christian since I was a kid though I struggle to get to church consistently these days. I was a teenager when I first started feeling depressed and anxious all the time, which I realized was compounded by my ADHD. The doctors have tried a lot of different medications over the years to help me but right now I am using an antidepressant, a mood stabilizer, a benzodiazepine and an amphetamine. The last two are tricky to manage because I need the amphetamine to focus and get my work done during the day but it's a stimulant so it makes me more anxious. The benzo helps me sleep or calm down in tense situations, but it also aggravates my ADHD. Sometimes I use THC oils when I feel stuck and can't escape the anxious thoughts or I just turn on Netflix for a while and that really helps. My wife recently left me because she didn't want to deal with the burden of helping someone who must work as hard as I do just to feel normal. She complained that I was always working on my own issues but didn't have time to deal with the needs of anyone else in the family. That whole process was incredibly traumatic, so I've had to set up some key boundaries like not letting our son and daughter talk to their mom on the phone while they are with me to keep myself from being re-traumatized.”
So that was Jonathan. Here is now the experience of a second person, a woman named Mallory. She writes, “I'm Mallory. I grew up in a legalistic church where we didn't hear much about God's grace or love, but we did get a lot of messages about the end times, the importance of dressing modestly and the danger of voting for Democrats. I had a lot of doubts as a young adult and really wanted someone in the church who was willing to openly discuss hard questions about the Bible. But during my first year of college my pastor said from the pulpit that people who doubt their "faith are just looking for an excuse to sleep around.” I stopped going to church after that because I didn't need to hear anymore triggering statements like that. I am grateful, though, because through social media I found a supportive community of people who understand my story. They encouraged me to consider that I might be suffering from complex post-traumatic stress disorder and that my concerns about church might have been fueled by a previously undiagnosed autism. When I researched both of these disorders it felt like a revelation, when I realized how well these disorders explained my feelings. My online community also helped me see that my mother seems to have narcissistic personality disorder and that it's better for my emotional health to go no contact with my family of origin as long as they refuse to acknowledge the traumatic dynamics of my childhood. I've also found a really supportive therapist who validates all of these insights.”
Now as I read both of those statements to you, you may have picked up on the fact that both Jonathan and Mallory articulated some sort of Christian identity. Jonathan was the one who said, “I've been a Christian since I was a kid” and Mallory directly linked former church experiences to the trauma she said she later went through. But as you also heard, Jonathan and Mallory in adulthood also embraced certain terminology and certain definitions which are very much at odds with their being rooted in Christ. Listen to some of the buzzwords again that the two of them used in those quotes: traumatic, boundaries, re-traumatized, triggering, disorder, feelings, emotional health, therapist, social media, validation. What you don't hear from either of them, Jonathan or Mallory, is any mention of a pastor or more widely speaking any mention of a church community, a body of Believers shepherding them through their struggles. Nor do you hear any mention of what God's Word has to say about what either of them is going through. Rather, both of these individuals, Jonathan and Mallory, are saturated, awash in “therapy speak,” in “trauma speak.” The way that each has shared their stories it is obvious that both Jonathan and Mallory do have some sort of supportive group that has surrounded them. They have therapists who have diagnosed them, a psychiatrist who has prescribed certain medications, social media voices who are quick to affirm them and to validate them. But note what is missing. There is no recognition of the fact in either case that what they are feeling or what they are going through might actually be sin. There is no mention of the wicked and foolish nature of the human heart which might actually be deceiving them. There is no sense of ownership or responsibility for their actions or for their feelings. There is not even a hint given at the thought of repentance. There is no mention of the cross of Jesus Christ who actually endured the most traumatic event anyone has experienced, ever. Again, there is no mention of what God through His Word would have either of them do in their respective situations, for instance to “take every thought captive,” II Corinthians 10:5, “in obedience to Jesus Christ.” Again, there is no mention of talking through any of this with a fellow member of the body of Christ, the Church, whether that be a pastor, a shepherd, an overseer or simply a fellow member of the body of Christ. Rather, both Jonathan and Mallory are converts to an entirely new religion—the religion of trauma and the religion of therapy—one which is defined necessarily by one's own experiences and where one's standard is a clinical list of diagnoses and disorders, where one's pastor is a psychologist and where one's shepherd is a social media voice or influencer.
Admittedly this morning is going to be a topical message, if you haven't picked up on that already. This is not a standard staple diet of what we do here at Indian Hills, normally we are working verse by verse through individual books of the Bible, going in the order God has laid things out. But every once in a while, I am convinced, and you all know this by now, that it is appropriate for me in this role as a pastor, as a shepherd of this flock, as the primary preaching voice here on Sundays to pause in our normal flow of things. Pause in our normal Sunday sermon flow and stand up before the church and issue some warnings about some issues that seem to be coming our way so that we can help all of us think through these matters Biblically. Today is one of those days, a day in which not only this morning but this evening I'm going to deliver these two messages which are going to engage with a couple of different cultural trends which originated outside the Church but have since very much so made their way inside the Church, impacting otherwise strong, faithful Bible centered Believers, potentially pulling them away from God's perfect design for them.
This morning's sermon is titled THE TRAP of TRAUMA and we're going to explore in this message how various therapeutic models are pulling otherwise well-intentioned Believers away from the truth that Scripture is sufficient. Then this evening I'll preach a sermon titled THE THIRST for the THERAPUTIC where we are going to look at a similar issue which is how many otherwise well-meaning Believers are now, in their quest for their answers and solutions to problems, being pulled away from the primacy of the local church. Now you're going to hear me mention more than once today that there really is a major point to each of these sermons that I want you to go away with. This won't just be me ripping on people who do things differently than we do them, rather I want to build you up and encourage and equip you with two principal truths, one coming this morning and one coming this evening. The main point to take away this morning is that GOD’S WORD is SUFFICIENT, and the main point that will be driven home this evening is that GODS CHURCH is the PLAN. If you don't normally come to Sunday evening service, this would be the Sunday to do so because these two messages are really a Part 1 and a Part 2, and you're going to be leaving a lot of meat on the bone if you come only this morning and don't come back for the evening message. But again, what I'm going to address this morning is THE TRAP of TRAUMA.
Now what I'm going to start sharing now as we unpack all this and this gets unrolled is going to be shared out of love for the members of this church, it's going to be shared out of a concern for the broader church, the broader evangelical church; And we're going to look at all this through the lens of God's Word. What we're really going to zero in on today, there are a number of different ways we could go with this, and I have to by definition and time limitations pick one. We're going to center in on this idea that's out there today of trauma informed counseling, a form of treatment or counseling that initially took root in secular circles but has since migrated over to Christian counseling circles as well. Now I should note lest we jump too far on the other side, that there is a form of helpful Bible-based counseling that is happening in faithful churches today, including in our church. This faithful form of Bible-based counseling is called Nouthetic Counseling; which is simply opening God's Word to provide solutions for fellow Believers. That word, Nouthetic Counseling comes from the words of Paul in Romans 15:14 where he says, “And I myself am also convinced about you, my brothers, that you yourselves are full of goodness, having been filled with all knowledge and being able also to admonish one another.” That word admonish, the Greek word is noutheteo and noutheteo can be translated admonish, but it can also be translated exhort, it can be translated rebuke and it can be translated faithfully counsel, meaning there is a place in the Christian's life and in Church life for fellow Believers to be counseling one another as a function of the one another ministry we all do all the time. But counseling one another with what? That's the issue. Well, just up the page from Romans 15:14 in Romans 15:4 it says, “For whatever was written in earlier times was written for our instruction so that through the perseverance and the encouragement of the Scriptures we might have hope.” There is the answer. Christians are called to counsel each other through the Scriptures, we are called to minister the Word of God to one another as we offer Biblical encouragement and exhortation to each other.
Well, what's making the rounds now in Christian circles today even among those who would say that they are committed to counseling each other through the Word; who might say that they are committed to Biblical admonishment. That they embrace the idea of Noutheteo Counseling from Romans 15:14, what's making the rounds today is this idea of trauma informed counseling. The premise underlying this form of counseling which more and more Christians are embracing and more and more Christian influencers are circulating through their various channels and pages, what is at the heart of this idea that people are necessarily defined by their past traumatic experiences, and because they are defined by their trauma, as the argument goes, they have to be counseled as such. According to this way of thinking, it is unproductive, it's unhelpful, it might even be accused as being unloving simply to take someone who has suffered through some form of traumatic experience to take them directly to the Word. Rather you need to, they would say, recognize that their trauma has left them in some sort of fragile and fragmented condition. You must understand that their traumatic experiences have left not only lasting emotional injury, but it has done a number on them physically also. You must understand that this person needs to be healed emotionally and physically before they can be ministered to spiritually and Biblically.
Now much of the conversation today surrounding this idea of trauma informed counseling stems from a 2014 book that was written by a Dutch psychiatrist named Bessel Van der Kolk, and the title of his book is The Body Keeps the Score. This book has been widely influential, highly popularized over the last 12 years, it has been translated into 43 different languages, it has stayed on the New York Times' Best Seller List for eight years, it is a very widely distributed, disseminated book. I mention this book, The Body Keeps the Score, not to recommend it to you, I wouldn't be downloading it on Kindle right now; but rather to highlight for you that this is the book which really kick started the whole trauma informed counseling movement as it exists today.
Now as the title of the book indicates, The Body Keeps the Score, in this book Van der Kolk is making the case that when memories of our past traumatic experiences are brought back to the forefront of our minds, and the word he would use there is trigger, when we are triggered to have those memories come back to the forefront of our minds. What is going to happen is that it is going to cause a number of different physical issues that will manifest in our bodies; whether that be things like panic attacks or anxiety attacks or hyperventilation or things of that nature. Now that's not all Van der Kolk said, he says that on a personal level when a person experiences trauma it so changes them from within that it changes their sense of self and their self-perception so radically that their trauma becomes in his words their “sole source of meaning.” In other words, their identity. Van der Kolk goes even further though he takes these thoughts about trauma to a society wide level, to a society wide level, to a societal level. He says that the trauma that individuals experience is the root of all behavioral, interpersonal, cultural and social issues we see around us today. So, whether that be patterns of substance abuse or physical abuse in a marriage or neglect of children or perpetual adolescence or the entire mental health crisis he refers to trauma as not being just one person's individual issue but a societal issue, indeed a public health issue. And in fact, he defines trauma as the most urgent public health issue of our time.
Now what does Van der Kolk suggest in terms of how somebody who has been traumatized is to work through that trauma? Well, he is not a Christian so he doesn't point his readers to the ordinary means that Christians have had for centuries to work through the various trials that come our way, He doesn't recommend prayer, he doesn't recommend involvement in a local church, he doesn't recommend opening God's Word. Rather, what Van der Kolk recommends are a series of physical tests which he says will reconnect the traumatized brain with the traumatized body. So, when we undergo trauma, he would say, our brain is no longer communicating with our body the way it ought to be communicating or the way it did before the trauma. But post trauma our senses are off and our bodies aren't right and so he recommends a number of physical tests that people should go through to sort of get things back in sync. But the point being he is thinking of these matters on a surface level, a physical level, a tactile level, a neurological level, not on a spiritual level.
Another thing to mention is about Van der Kolk and his theory of trauma. His definition of trauma is that he defines trauma as being incredibly broad. He uses a very broad definition. You know it wasn't all that long ago that the word trauma was reserved for the most gruesome physical injuries. That's what trauma was not that long ago. A trauma would mean your foot was blown off in Vietnam. A trauma would mean you got your car wrapped around a telephone pole while driving drunk and then they wheeled you in to the trauma ward of your local emergency room or hospital. In those circumstances those individuals clearly had traumatic injuries which threatened their very life and so they were treated as such. But what happened was gradually that word and that term trauma made its way over to the psychological realm where it was embraced by psychiatrists and psychologists alike. At that point, once the word made its way into that realm, that word trauma became not just about one's physical injuries, but it became more about the mental strain that people go through. For instance, in the military, back in the day when somebody had bullets whizzing over them perpetually on the field of battle they would come back and they would describe things like battle fatigue or combat exhaustion or shell shock. But now that same soldier comes back from Afghanistan or whatever country, and they are told that they have something called what? Post traumatic stress disorder. So, it's not symptoms anymore we're talking about, you're being assigned a condition.
Now once that word trauma migrated over to the psychological realm the dam completely broke and the floodwaters of psychological thought began rushing through. So now, according to Van der Kolk and a litany of psychiatrists and psychologists after him, trauma is not defined merely as some observable physical wound you've suffered like a bullet in your leg. Rather trauma is redefined as something that is unbearable or intolerable that you might have gone through like a breakup or a job change or another fourth quarter collapse. I didn't mean it that way, that's too soon. Trauma isn't limited to some severe catastrophic physical event that someone has gone through, rather trauma is defined as some mentally straining circumstance that a person had to endure, like being called a name or having a bill come due or having a teacher hand out a pop quiz at the beginning of class. Nowadays if a series of events or circumstances brings about some sort of a negative emotional response in someone, it's more and more likely to be labeled as traumatic.
Now that's a lot of secular psychology for one morning at Indian Hills, a lot more than I am comfortable sharing but I think it's important to tease this out and to set this all up for us because the reality is what Van der Kolk was articulating in that 2014 book and which has spread like wildfire ever since is it really has jumped a fire line of sort, a way out of the entirely or exclusively secular realm and into the church world where again now you have people who would call themselves Christian counselors, even Biblical counselors, who are embracing some version of Van der Kolk's ideas about trauma. Now these Christian counselors aren't necessarily running all the physical tests that Van der Kolk would have them run, but what they are doing is embracing his larger premise that our trauma really defines who we are. That before we minister God's Word to someone, we first need to consider their trauma and factor in how their trauma might be defining them or limiting them to receive the Word of God.
So where do we go with this? How do we proceed from here? Where do we go with this idea of trauma and specifically with the notion of trauma informed counseling? Well, we reject it. That's where we go with it, we reject it. And we reject it because of our commitment to the truth of God's Word, but we reject it because of our convictions about the sufficiency of God's Word, and we reject it because of the reality of the content of God's Word. The contents of God's Word which speak loudly and broadly on the subject of suffering and if you want to use the term, fine, even on the subject of trauma.
Enough of the psychological stuff, let's lay out some of the Biblical principles related to the sufficiency of God's Word. Remember if you take one thing away from this message this morning it is that God's Word is sufficient. Let's build that out a little bit as we remember and reflect upon the sufficiency of God's Word. The reality is we worship a God who has given us in Scripture His very word. He has breathed out His word for our benefit. II Timothy 3:16, “All Scripture is God breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for training in righteousness so that the man of God may be equipped, having been thoroughly equipped for every good work.” So note that, the Bible has been breathed out by God, and that word God breathed, theopneustos, it means that the human authors of Scripture—Moses and David and Ezra and Peter and Paul—wrote exactly what they did as humans in their own distinct style but at the same time what they wrote was governed by and superintended by the Holy Spirit so that what the human author wrote God was actually saying through them. So, to say that Scripture is God breathed, then, is to say that the words of Scripture are God's own words. We hold in our hands the very word of the living God. Because it has been breathed out by God another key truth we affirm and know is that Scripture is inerrant, it is without error. We know that God is not only a God who is truthful as a matter of His character, but He is a God of truth and because He is truth what He has given us is truth. It is truth itself. Jesus said in the high priestly prayer, John 17:17, “Your word is truth.” We read in the Scripture reading from this morning Psalm 19:7, “The Law of the Lord,” the Word of God, “is perfect.”
So not only has God's word been divinely breathed out by Him and not only is God's Word without error, but another principle also that we affirm and know is that God has given us a clear word. His Word is clear, it is understandable. Psalm 119:105 says that His “word is a lamp to our feet and a light to our path.” Again, God is a God of truth, not of confusion; God is a God of light, not a God of darkness; and God has given us precepts in His word that He has made accessible to us, understandable to us and clear for us to take in and apply to our lives. In fact, Scripture itself testifies to its clarity. Remember in that scene in Matthew 12 where Jesus and the Pharisees had that confrontation about Jesus's disciples eating the showbread. In Matthew 12:3 Jesus says, “Have you not read what David did, when he became hungry, he and his companions, how he entered the house of God and they ate the consecrated bread?” Or the very next verse in Matthew 12:5 He says, “Have you not read in the Law that on the sabbath the priests in the temple break the sabbath and are innocent?” In Matthew 19:4 Jesus encounters a Pharisee and says, “Have you not read that He who created them from the beginning made them male and female?” Or Matthew 21:42 the Lord says, “Did you never read in the Scriptures the stone which the builders rejected, this has become the chief cornerstone?”
Now note the assumption that is undergirding each of those questions from Jesus to those various crowd members. The assumption is what? That these scholars, that these teachers of the Law, that these religious hypocrites had not only received and read the Word of God but they were capable of understanding the Word of God. And they were able to do so because God's Word is clear. Jesus wouldn't have asked them those questions if God's Word were foggy or murky or unclear. It wasn't only Jesus who would ask words like that or make points like that. Again, Paul, I've read this already to you, but Romans 15:4, Paul says in that passage, “For whatever was written in earlier times was written for our instruction so that through the perseverance and encouragement of the Scriptures we might have hope.” Now note that progression of thought there. The Scriptures instruct us, the Scriptures encourage us and the Scriptures then give us hope. The bridge that connects the fact that the Scriptures encourage us and instruct us and then give us hope, the bridge between all of those is the doctrine of the clarity of Scripture. Because the Scripture is clear, because if we are Believers, we have the Spirit in us to illuminate the Scriptures for us as we interact with it, because the Scripture is clear we can derive hope from it and encouragement from it.
Scripture is God breathed, Scripture is without error, Scripture is clear and then here is the one we want to take away with us today for our purposes, Scripture is sufficient. Scripture is absolutely sufficient. The words that God has given us on the pages of His Word, the pages of the Bible give us all that we need to navigate this life. In the Scripture God has, by His divine power, told us in II Peter 1:3 that “He has given us everything pertaining to life and to godliness.” Does He tell you what kind of oil to put in your car? No. Does He tell you which sports teams to root for? No. Does He give you everything pertaining to life and godliness? Absolutely. He Himself has said so. So, nothing can be added to Scripture, nothing can be layered on top of Scripture as it relates to living for the Lord in this life. Scripture is sufficient. And the fact that Scripture is sufficient is derived from, and we see it first and foremost, in the Scripture itself. Scripture, in other words, attests to its own sufficiency. Like in Deuteronomy 4 God gave His promises there to the people of Israel through Moses. He gives these words in Deuteronomy 4:2 which show that the Word that He gave to the Israelites was sufficient. He says, “You shall not add to the word which I am commanding you nor take away from it, that you may keep the commandments of Yahweh your God which I am commanding you.” That is a statement about the sufficiency of Scripture. “You shall not add to it,” He says to Moses. Or there are the familiar words of Paul in II Timothy 3:16-17, again, “All Scripture is God breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for training in righteousness so that the man of God may be equipped,” and then “having been thoroughly equipped,” he says, “for good work.” That's a statement about the sufficiency of Scripture. Scripture is the authority we turn to for all of life as Christians. Anyone who would want to obey the will of God as any child of God would want to do, what they are going to do is turn to the Scripture. All pertaining to life and godliness can be found in the Scripture.
So why would we here at Indian Hills reject the notion and the whole idea of what is being peddled out there as trauma informed counseling? We would reject it in light of all that I've just laid out for you about our commitment to the sufficiency of God's Word. To the sufficiency of Scripture where God has given us all that is needed pertaining to life and godliness. Knowing that truth from God Himself, who would we be to add to Scripture? Who would we be to filter Scripture through the lens of trauma or anything else?
Here is another thing to consider in response to those who are seeking or promoting trauma informed counseling, and that's the content of God's Word. So, we've laid out the fact that the Scripture is sufficient. Another thing we need to consider is what is actually revealed to us in Scripture speaks loudly and compellingly on the subject of hurt and grief and danger and damage, and if you want to use that term, fine, trauma. See, secularists like Van der Kolk in that book, The Body Keeps the Score, they are really covering territory that the Bible covered centuries ago, centuries and centuries ago. Though to sell books they are presenting these ideas as though they are full of originality and brilliance, they actually aren't being original at all because God has already spoken about these matters comprehensively and sufficiently in His Word. Does Scripture say anything about suffering? Yes, of course. Absolutely Scripture says much about suffering. In fact, we did an entire conference like six weeks ago at the Entrusted Conference which the whole theme was the Christian and Suffering and how to think Biblically about the suffering that we as Believers will endure. Now I'm not going to summarize all of the messages you heard at the conference, but I do want to highlight some of the highlights of some key principles that we need to think through here. For starters the Bible teaches not that we are a mere composition of physical, material elements—brains and bodies. Rather the witness of Scripture is that we are embodied souls. Every one of you here this morning is an immaterial soul, that is what you are. You just happen to be encased in a human body, some male, some female, some young, some old, some with lots of hair, some with less, some from one part of town, some from another. But you are all souls encased in flesh and body, that's what we are. The reality is both soul and body have become corrupted as a result of the fall, as a result of sin entering into this world. That's the testimony of Scripture.
Now a secular psychologist like Van der Kolk is going to be focused more on the physical side of things and more on the emotional side of things. He is going to be looking to root our behaviors and symptoms, he's going to be looking to fix the outside, to apply a therapeutic band-aid to the situation. But God's Word teaches us over and over something entirely different. The Bible says nothing about; there's not even a hint about mere band-aid solutions to what ultimately for all of us are heart level struggles and heart problems. That's why it says in Hebrews 4:12 that “the Word of God is living and active and sharper than any two-edged sword and piercing as far as the division of soul and spirit of both joints and marrow,” and then what does it say next? “And able to judge the thoughts and intentions of the heart.” That's what Scripture does, it gets at the heart. Or consider the words of Jesus as He is encountering the Pharisees about all their legalistic traditions in Mark 7, this is Mark 7:21 where He says to them, “From within out of the heart of men proceed the evil thoughts, sexual immoralities, thefts, murders, adulteries, coveting, wickedness, deceit, sensuality, envy, slander, pride and foolishness. All these proceed from within and defile the man.” Then you go back to the Old Testament, and you get to the book of Proverbs and Proverb 4:23 says, “Guard your heart with all diligence for from it flow the springs of life.” So, the Biblical witness is these are always heart level matters, not surface level matters that you can simply apply a therapeutic bandage to.
Here is another item, those who affirm this idea of trauma informed counseling influenced by men like Van der Kolk are going to speak in terms of conditions and disorders and diagnoses. They are going to use that buzzword of a term, trauma, in a way which suggests that traumatic experiences are somehow abnormal in the life of a follower of Christ. But the Bible says no such thing. The Bible says the complete opposite. The Bible is full of references to affliction and hardship and suffering and trials and the Bible is completely clear, crystal clear, that followers of Christ are not to be surprised when we suffer but rather, we are to expect suffering and anticipate suffering even if the suffering that we are experiencing is what the world might call trauma. Recall what Jesus said in John 16:33, He said, “In the world you have tribulation.” You will have tribulation, He says, it is going to happen. But then He says this as a way to encourage those who are listening to those words as He declared them to encourage them to keep marching forward in faith. He said, “But take courage, I have overcome the world.” Or consider these words from Peter in I Peter 4:12, he says. “Beloved, do not be surprised at the fiery trial among you which comes upon you for your testing as though some strange things were happening to you.” But then he says next in verse 13, “But to the degree you are sharing the sufferings of Christ,” and then he takes it up a notch, he says, “Keep on rejoicing so that at the revelation of His glory you may rejoice with exaltation.” So, we have the reality of trials, we have the expectation of trials, now we have Peter saying we ought to be rejoicing when we suffer, rejoicing when we go through incredibly deep lows and valleys even in this life.
Someone who understood what Peter is saying there in I Peter 4:13, somebody who not only affirmed it intellectually but lived it out experientially was a woman named Helen Roseveare. Helen Roseveare was a British missionary to the Congo from 1953-1973, and Roseveare went through the horrifying experience of being raped by Congo soldiers while she was there on post as a missionary. She was there to give medical care and attention, and she was brutalized by a group of men there in the Congo. Just this horrific experience, a tragic experience, one which by any definition anyone would say is traumatic. Listen to this. Years later in her later years after returning to Britain, Roseveare would write this about that very experience. She says, “And suddenly there was God. I didn't see a vision, I didn't hear a voice, I just knew with every ounce of my being that God was actually, vitally there. God in all His majesty and power. He stretched out His arms to me, He surrounded me with His love, and He seemed to whisper to me, twenty years ago you asked Me for the privilege of being a missionary. This is it; do you want it? Fantastic, the privilege of being identified with our Savior. As I was driven down the short corridor of my home it was as though He clearly said to me, These are not your sufferings, they are not beating you. These are My sufferings. All I ask you is the loan of your body. And an enormous relief swept through me.”
Now you want to talk about somebody who had a stark understanding of what it means to undergo suffering and undergo trauma, that would have been this woman, Helen Roseveare. But it comes through so clearly in what she wrote that what she also understood from this very obviously well-informed Biblical worldview, she understood starkly that suffering, even to that level, is the lot of the Christian. So much so that she could find peace in those horrifying experiences that she endured. She was like Paul who could say in Romans 5:3 not that we run from our difficulty, not that we crumple in the face of our trials, not that we create a separate category for our trauma, but he says in Romans 5:3, “we boast in our afflictions, knowing that our affliction brings about perseverance and perseverance proven character and proven character hope.” And then he says, “and hope does not put to shame because the love of God has been poured out within our hearts through the Holy Spirit who was given to us.” Because of that identity that we have in Christ, because we know who we are in Christ, because we know where we are going in light of what Christ has done for us these really are light and momentary afflictions even though in the moment, they don't feel like them. The trauma centered worldview which is driving the trauma informed counseling movement of today really flips these notions on their head by implying that suffering in this fallen world is abnormal or that grief and anxiety and worry in this world is somehow abnormal, or by implying at least that this world is supposed to be some sort of pain free paradise.
But God has told us the exact opposite in His Word. I mean, to give you a sense of how real the Scriptural narrative is, how raw the Scriptures are, how in tune the Scriptures are with what the world is calling trauma today, consider just a few of these examples. You are welcome to turn to these; I'm just going to run through them rapid fire. But Job, the book of Job, in Job 9:17 Job says, “For He bruises me,” he's talking about God and I'm not trying to argue here that he is right and justified in his arguments against God here but look what he identifies. Job 9:17, “For He bruises me with a tempest and multiplies my wounds without cause. He will not allow me to get my breath but saturates me with bitterness.” Job there refers to the anxiety he was experiencing which was pressing in on him so severely that it was like he couldn't catch his breath. Then Job earlier in that same book in Job 3:3 describes hopelessness. He says, “Let the day perish on which I was to be born and the night which said a man is conceived. May that day be darkness, let not God seek it from above nor light shine on it.” So, there are expressions of anxiety and hopelessness. Now we move over to David and David was known in his writings in the Psalms specifically for describing all types of suffering and all types of emotion and experience, like the physical afflictions his suffering brought him. Here is Psalm 6:2, he says, “Be gracious to me, oh Yahweh, for I am pining away. Heal me, oh Yahweh, for my bones are dismayed.” Or Psalm 31:9, “Be gracious to me, oh Yahweh, for I am in distress, my eye has wasted away from grief, my soul and my body also.” David also expressed these feelings of abandonment and exhaustion at various times. Psalm 22:1, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me? For from my salvation are the words of my groaning. Oh my God, I call by day, but you do not answer and by night, but I have no rest.” Then Psalm 102:7, we have the anonymous psalmist describing the unbearable loneliness he was experiencing. He says there, “I lie awake, I become like a lonely bird on a roof.” Jeremiah, the weeping prophet, described a wide range of troubled feelings he was working through like being downcast and depressed. Lamentations 3:17, he says, “My soul has been rejected from peace, I have forgotten goodness, so I say my strength has perished as well as my hopeful waiting which comes from Yahweh.” Then in that same chapter, Jeremiah 3:46, he describes these feelings of panic associated with the sacking of Jerusalem. He says, “All our enemies have opened their mouths against us, panic and pitfall have befallen us.” So over and over these expressions of anxiety and depression and exhaustion and physical symptoms, all these worries and concerns.
We take it all together and we see here from the Biblical narrative that suffering is normal, suffering is par for the course, suffering is the things that Believers go through in a fallen world. Now suffering might look different for you than it does for others. We all suffer differently, that's why James says in James 1:2, “Count it all joy, my brothers, when you encounter various trials.” There is a variety in the trials that we experience, but our trials and our griefs and our suffering and yes, our trauma is all part of life under the sun.
Now God does something through our suffering, doesn't He. He sure does. That is part of what He has revealed to us, and it is part of what we can testify to experientially. In that same passage, James 1:2, “Count it all joy, my brothers, when you experience trials of various kinds,” he then says in verse 3, “knowing that the testing of your faith brings about perseverance and let perseverance have its perfect work so that you may be perfect and complete, lacking in nothing.” He sanctifies us through our suffering. Peter says it almost identically in I Peter 1:6-7, he says, “In this you greatly rejoice even though now for a little while if necessary you have been grieved by various trials so that the proof of your faith being more precious than gold which is perishable even though tested by fire may be found to result in praise and glory and honor at the revelation of Jesus Christ.” What all that is testifying to is that God is growing us and He is sanctifying us in and through our suffering. He is confirming our faith in our suffering, He is conforming us into the image of our Savior the Lord Jesus Christ through our suffering. Our suffering then, our trauma if that's your preferred term, is not purposeless, it's not meaningless, it's not a reason to go inward as we reflect on how everything is making us feel. Rather it's a reason to go upward as we praise God for what He is doing through us in our struggles and in our suffering as we reflect on the character of God. As we reflect on promises like these, like in Psalm 46:1, “God is our refuge and strength, a very present help in trouble.” Or Psalm 34:18, “Yahweh is near to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit.”
So, we aren't to think about our most difficult life's experiences, our difficulties, our stresses, our trials through the lens of being victims or through the lens of having been traumatized. Rather, we are to think about our suffering through the lens of God's presence in our life and His purpose in our life. We are to be like Joseph who would say all those years later in Genesis 50:20, “What they designed for evil God intended for good.” We are to say like Paul in Romans 8:28 that “for those who love God all things work together for good for those who are called according to His purpose.” See, the question is not whether we can nod our heads in affirmation today on a Sunday morning about some of these truths I'm reading off for you; the question is whether we would agree with those truths and live out those truths in the deepest of our valleys.
What this whole idea of trauma and victimhood and counseling those who are holding onto that label, what this whole idea does fundamentally is it redefines one's identity, it confuses one's identity. What does the Bible say, what does God's Word say about who we are as Christians? Let me just encourage you with a laundry list of some of the things that God tells you about who you are if you are a follower of Christ. Number one it starts with affirming and recognizing and remembering that you have been made in the image of God. Genesis 1:27, “God created man in His own image, in the image of God He created him, male and female He created them.” You are an image bearer. Number two, you are, as a human, at the very pinnacle of God's creation. Psalm 8:4-5, “What is man that you remember him and the son of man that you care for him? Yet you have made him a little lower than the angels and you crown him with glory and majesty,” it says. The Bible teaches us, third, that in our original state we came into this world, though image bearers, though the pinnacle of God's creation, dead. Dead in our sin. Ephesians 2:1, “You were dead in your transgressions and sin.” The Bible then teaches us that by grace through faith, if we put our faith in Jesus, that we've been saved. Ephesians 2:5, “Even when we were dead in our transgression God made us alive together with Christ, by grace you have been saved.” The Bible then teaches that in light of God's saving work in our life we have been made new creations in Christ. We are under completely new management. II Corinthians 5:17, “Therefore if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; behold, old things have passed, new things have come.” The Bible teaches that our position is secure in Christ. Jesus said in John 10:27, “My sheep hear My voice, and I know them and they follow Me and I give eternal life to them and they will never perish, ever. And no one will snatch them out of My hand.” The Bible teaches that no matter what happens in these physical bodies here on earth, no matter how much stress, difficulty, trauma these bodies endure our future is secure. II Corinthians 4:16, “Therefore we do not lose heart but though our outer man is decaying yet our inner man is being renewed day by day. For our momentary light affliction is working out for us an eternal weight of glory far beyond all comparison while we look not at the things which are seen but at the things are not seen. For the things which are seen are temporal but the things which are not seen are eternal.”
So you take all that data and you put it all together and what we see very clearly is that the Bible does not say that we are victims of our circumstances or that we are victims of trauma or any such thing, rather the Bible's narrative teaches us things like we are fearfully and wonderfully made and we are co-heirs with Christ and we are chosen and redeemed and forgiven children of light. We are not victims, we are victors. We are not fighters, we are conquerors. We are not survivors, we are slaves, slaves of our Master the Lord Jesus Christ. That's who God says we are in light of our position, our secure position in Christ. That is true no matter how difficult and how trying and how traumatic our life experiences might be; no matter what we go through after being saved. And that's also true no matter what the secularist in the therapeutic realm might otherwise say about who we are.
I would be remiss if I didn't take this opportunity to remind you, and I've alluded to it already, that no one in the history of the world has suffered more and endured more and experienced more significant trauma than our Lord Jesus Himself. The Lord Jesus, the eternal Son of God was dwelling in eternity past in perfect trinitarian fellowship and He left His Father's right hand, He left that glorious position to come to this earth to do what? To die, to be a slave, to suffer on behalf of sinners like us. Philippians 2:6 says that “Christ although existing in the form of God did not regard equality with God a thing to be grasped but emptied Himself by taking the form of a slave, be being made in the likeness of men. Being found in appearance as a man He humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross.” Now we know as we go back into the Old Testament that even hundreds of years before Christ came it was prophesied of Him that He would come to suffer greatly and to die. Isaiah 53:4, speaking 700 years ahead of the birth of Christ writes, “Surely our griefs He Himself bore and our sorrows He carried. Yet we ourselves esteemed Him stricken, smitten of God and afflicted. But He was pierced through for our transgressions, He was crushed for our iniquities. The chastening for our peace fell upon Him and by His wounds we are healed. All of us like sheep have gone astray, each of us has turned to his own way, but Yahweh has caused the iniquity of us all to fall on Him.” The next time you are tempted to assign victim status to yourself, think of Christ. The next time you are tempted to think that no one has suffered the way that you have suffered, think of Christ. The Scottish pastor, I think it was from the 1800s, Robert Murray M'Cheyne, famously said, “For every look at self-take ten looks at Christ.” I think that's a helpful perspective to remember that no one ever endured more trauma than the bleeding, heaving, sweating, groaning, flogged, crucified Lord of glory. No one. No one ever endured more trauma than did Jesus the Lamb of God who, as He died for the sins of the world, healed. “By His wounds,” I Peter 2:24, “you were healed.” What that means is those who have already been healed, spiritually healed, by having our sins forgiven is we can look to the Savior. Knowing that through our suffering, our inevitable suffering, through our trauma, if that's the word you want to use, He is conforming us into His image. He is preparing us for glory. II Corinthians 3:18, “But we all with unveiled face, beholding as in a mirror the glory of the Lord, are being conformed into the same image from glory to glory, just as from the Lord the Spirit.” For every look at yourself, take ten looks at Christ.
I'm going to wind down here with a story and it's admittedly a very personal story. As many of you know, because I've shared my testimony in a number of different public settings since coming here, I have a divorce in my background, a divorce I went through many years ago in a much different phase of my life when I didn't yet know Jesus as Savior and Lord, when I was still very much, Ephesians 2:1, “dead in my sin.” Now though that divorce that I went through was entirely of my own accord and my initiative the divorce and its consequences in those days following it absolutely crushed me. My two young children at the time were in the crossfire, they were these innocent victims of Dad's sinful choices. And whenever I would think about what I had done to them and the complications in life I had created for them it just wrecked me, I remember in those days I couldn't even sit down for a meal with somebody and talk with them and use my kids' names, Emerson and Amelia, without tears welling up and my lip quivering and sometimes just crying. I was like David in Psalm 32 when he says, “When I kept silent about my sins my bones wasted away through my groaning all day long.” I could totally relate to what David was going through. Now in the meantime I had gotten remarried to my beautiful wife, Jenna, and at the time here we were, these two unbelievers who, unbeknownst to us, God was going to save in the months to come, but we were having these marital problems. And somehow, we ended up in the office of a marriage counselor, a lady in her mid-40s, mid-50s, something like that. She may have had some religious affiliation, I didn't know or care at the time. But as Jenna and I sat on her couch and as we walked her through our whole story up to that point and explained the whole picture of why we were there—a divorce, remarriage, kids involved, step parenting, these feelings of guilt and remorse, crippling alimony and child support payments, a bunch of other unhealthy practices I was at that time bringing into the marriage—I'll never forget it, this marriage counselor, rather than offering some sort of constructive, positive word of consolation, of even encouragement or even like an affirming nod, she didn't offer anything like that. Instead with us pouring our hearts out to her, this counselor looked at us and tears were welling up in her eyes and she just said, that's just so sad. We were like, yeah, that's why we are here. We know our life is a train wreck, we know our life is a mess, we know what has gotten us here. That's why we're paying you actually to help us through our problems. But that's what she said, that's just so sad, and she was in tears. Now back then I think Jenna and I would likely have defined ourselves as victims, we would probably have said something like we've traumatized each other, the kind of things we were saying to each other back in those days. I mean, we were treading water, maritally speaking, if not getting close to drowning. But this counselor offered us no hope, zero hope, just by crying and telling us, that's sad. Now fast forward a few months when the Lord saw fit to open both of our eyes in bringing us to saving faith in Jesus Christ.
When I came to Christ, I remember as a brand new convert thinking to myself, I guess you could even say pledging within myself that if I ever had the opportunity to share with someone just how empty the whole world of secular therapeutic counseling methodologies is, I was going to jump at that opportunity. Now truth be told I had more in mind like a one-on-one kind of discussion with a brother in Christ, I wasn't thinking of an auditorium full of people, but here we are. Now back then I could have affirmed certain things that Jesus was a way, I'm talking about before I was saved, but when He opened my eyes in saving faith and when He revealed to me as He does to each of us that His Word is truth, I realized we had something here that we could truly cling to—that Scripture is sufficient. Now as sinners, though saved sinners, we are going to continually interact in this world with other sinners. We are going to be sinned against, we are going to be offended, we are going to be maligned, we are going to be treated poorly, we are going to be violated in various different ways, but the answer to how we are to carry ourselves and conduct ourselves when we are targeted and when we are accused and when we are unfairly treated and when we are shamed and when we are hurt or grieved or accosted or berated or anything like that, the answer is not to look within and the answer is not to soak in the tepid waters of feeling traumatized. Rather, the answer is to look above, and the answer is to look to this Book for answers, for guidance, for truth and for hope. Again, Romans 15:4, “For whatever was written in earlier times was written for our instruction so that through the perseverance and the encouragement of the Scriptures we might have hope.”
THE TRAP of TRAUMA, tonight THE THIRST for the THERAPUTIC.
.